Fiore & Tony's Pizza

Discover delicious, old-fashioned pizza at Fiore & Tony's Pizza in Andover, OH. Enjoy flavorful sausage, mushroom toppings, stromboli, and great prices in a cozy area—perfect for camping trips and family outings. Call +1 440-293-6148!

Welcome to Fiore & Tony's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Fiore & Tony's Pizza
Fiore & Tony's Pizza
Fiore & Tony's Pizza
Fiore & Tony's Pizza

Dive into Fiore & Tony's Pizza, a cozy pizza haven located at 92 Public Sq, Andover, OH. This charming spot serves mouthwatering pizza and hearty salads at reasonable prices, making it a favorite among locals. Families flock here after camping trips or sports games, drawn in by the aroma of fresh dough and sizzling toppings. Whether it’s a quick slice or a full pie, every meal here brings a sense of nostalgia with its old-fashioned recipes and warm atmosphere.

Perfect for a family outing or a casual date, customers appreciate the inviting vibe and the care put into every dish. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in a slice of Andover’s beloved pizza destination.

Location & Contact

Address

92 Public Sq, Andover, OH 44003, United States

Phone

+1 440-293-6148

Social Media

About

Fiore & Tony's Pizza
Fiore & Tony's Pizza
Fiore & Tony's Pizza
Fiore & Tony's Pizza

Since opening, Fiore & Tony's Pizza has become an integral part of Andover's dining scene. Locally owned, this pizza gem presents dishes that reflect traditional Italian culinary art while embracing the flavors that fans adore. Most patrons rave about the hearty sausage and mushroom toppings, combined with the rich, savory cheese melted to perfection on their freshly baked pies.

With options for every palate, even non-pizza lovers find something to enjoy, from crispy jalapeño poppers to cheesy mozzarella sticks, all crafted to offer satisfaction in each bite.

Fiore & Tony's emphasizes community connection, often hosting events or promotions that bring neighbors together. This creates not just a dining spot but a community hub.

Patrons frequently partake in cheerful banter that fills the space, fostering a welcoming environment. Customers return not only for the delicious meals but also for the friendships built within these four walls. Several families even commemorate special occasions with cakes and pizza parties here, a testament to how this place brings people together. With daily specials that keep the menu exciting and prices that accommodate all wallets, Fiore & Tony's offers unmatched value in Andover. Repeat visitors often express their joy over the consistent quality and friendly service.

Work Hours

  • Sunday4-8:30 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • WednesdayClosed
  • Thursday4-8:30 PM
  • Friday4-8:30 PM
  • Saturday4-8:30 PM

Fiore & Tony's Pizza boasts an impressive menu with over 11 delicious options. Popular choices include their perfectly balanced sausage pizza, scrumptious stromboli, and delectable breadsticks with cheese. The menu also features a variety of salads, allowing diners to mix and match as they please. The small chef salad and tossed salad cater to those desiring a lighter option, while large portions satisfy even the hungriest customers. And the average prices hover around $7.64, making it an accessible dining choice for all budgets. Takeout is efficient and fast, ideal for a busy weeknight or impromptu gatherings. Regulars savor the vibrant atmosphere, where community and conversation grow as naturally as the food.

Fiore & Tony's Pizza

The exterior of Fiore & Tony's Pizza exudes charm and warmth. Nestled in the heart of Andover, the well-kept signage beckons patrons to step inside. The outdoor seating area invites guests to enjoy a meal al fresco, perfect for those sunny Ohio afternoons. The local vibe radiates from every table, crafting a convivial atmosphere where laughter and conversation flow freely. Tall trees lining the public square provide a scenic backdrop, enhancing the outing experience and making it an enjoyable stop for families.

Customer Reviews

Small family run establishment! Has that great family vibe. Ordered for the first time and will definitely be back. Simple menu that gets right to the point. Great pizza! You can tell they care about quality.!

K
Kenneth N.

Best pizza .it's good fresh .friendly service love

D
Debbie S.

The best pizza in town...real provolone cheese..family run forever...only open Thursday through Sunday at 4 pm

A
Aric B.

Best pizza ever friendly service great prices he blessed us with a hot loaf of leftover dough and we were tearing hunks off and eating it going down road on trike

K
Kris K.

Had pizza here for the first time. We really enjoyed it. It was a pepperoni pizza. Will be going back. My only regret was that it took me a long time to find this pizza place.

E
Ed E.

This is an old fashion pizza shop with a cast iron pizza oven. Unlike many of the other places in town who don't make the dough, they still do which is a huge plus considering all the preservatives and additives elsewhere. Good prices, great pizza, and good old fashion simplicity! Going into this place is always a reminder of a time when things were simpler and more authentic.

N
Nicholas C.